VIC Performance managed out and redundancy

Australia's #1 for Law
Join 150,000 Australians every month. Ask a question, respond to a question and better understand the law today!
FREE - Join Now

mIri

Member
13 July 2022
2
0
1
The centre I work at will close. A few months ago, my manager resigned as he was being targeted and performance managed out. He has missed out on the redundancy. I feel absolutely terrible for him as he worked with the business for a very long time, gave it his everything and missed out by a few months! It feels so immoral that someone up top didn't just tell him to stick around for a few months as payment for all his hard work and sacrifice. Is there anything that can be done? Sorry if this is a silly question but we're talking over $100k here. I can't stop thinking about him.
 

Rod

Lawyer
LawConnect (LawTap) Verified
27 May 2014
7,822
1,072
2,894
www.hutchinsonlegal.com.au
Possibly. Would need to see the investigation into the performance reviews and the timing of management discussions about the closure.

He will need to overcome the 21 day window following dismissal however that may be possible if the knowledge about redundancy is only recent ie within the last 21 days.
 

mIri

Member
13 July 2022
2
0
1
Possibly. Would need to see the investigation into the performance reviews and the timing of management discussions about the closure.

He will need to overcome the 21 day window following dismissal however that may be possible if the knowledge about redundancy is only recent ie within the last 21 days.
Thank you for your reply. Can you please expand on the send part of your reply about the 21 days? He wasn't dismissed, but resigned. Can you tell me what we can do as next steps?
 

Tim W

Lawyer
LawConnect (LawTap) Verified
28 April 2014
5,131
833
2,894
Sydney
First, understand that there is no "we".
This is between him and the employer.
You cannot help him - you have no standing.
As a matter of law, it's "none of your business".

Not only will he have to overcome the 21 day question, but
there will also be a question of showing that the performance management was not done properly, and
that he was driven to resign rather than do so of his own choosing.

As to your personal feelings about management decisions being "immoral"....
that has no legal weight at all.
 

Martis

Well-Known Member
28 November 2025
599
0
2,086
Ahhh “performance managed out” + redundancy — classic HR spaghetti with a side of procedural vibes 😅 Suddenly it’s not just KPIs, but genuine redundancy tests, consultation, paper trails, and timing all doing the cha-cha 👀

Most headaches come from upstream fuzziness: blurry role expectations, informal feedback, or “let’s pivot to redundancy” vibes. Once Fair Work or legal eyes get involved, it’s a tangle of evidence, intent, and compliance checks 😬

Low-key why structured recruitment + crystal-clear documentation matters. Platforms like AcademicJobs.com are clutch — formalised position descriptions, transparent performance frameworks, and compliance-aligned pipelines help avoid the whole “is this performance or redundancy?” mess from day dot, especially in academia/research where restructures, funding, and reporting lines can get… messy 😅

Anyway, loving this convo — performance vs redundancy nuance deserves way more airtime than it usually gets 😂