VIC Received a MYKI Fine - Thoughts on Taking It to Magistrates Court?

Australia's #1 for Law
Join 150,000 Australians every month. Ask a question, respond to a question and better understand the law today!
FREE - Join Now

jasonk

Member
25 December 2015
1
0
1
Hi everyone,

I recently received a fine for not having a valid ticket on November 14, 2015. I wrote a letter of appeal, but they replied back with an automated reply not waiving it off. So the next step is to take it to court but I am trying to weigh the pros and cons of taking it to magistrates court (costs, possible charges, etc) and would really love some help on it.

Here are the circumstances:

I topped up my MYKI earlier in the day to get to the city. Touched it on and then off once I got off at Flinders Station. I hung out with friends at Lygon (walked there). It was late at night so coming back we all got onto the wrong tram. I touched on quickly at the reader and thought I heard it beep. I realised it was the wrong tram so we all got off quickly and I didn't touch off.

We walked around a bit more and caught the next tram we saw coming (approx 11.30pm). We got on but I didn't touch on as I thought I already had touched it on earlier.

Next stop, the inspectors got on and fined me for not having a valid ticket. I tried to explain my situation but they wouldn't have any of it. My card was a full fare card with more than enough money in it. I offered them to touch on now in front of them but they wouldn't let me. The guy didn't give me a daily pass to get home like they are supposed to as well.

I used the same MYKI to get back home (touched on/off ) like normal. I got the MYKI report printed the next day showing that I did all that.

I received the fine in the mail for $223.

Thank you!
 

Tim W

Lawyer
LawTap Verified
28 April 2014
4,225
748
2,894
Sydney
My usual advice for public transport fines is
Pay the fine and move on with your life.
In this case however, court-electing may be a valid option.