WA Landlord withholding bond

Australia's #1 for Law
Join 150,000 Australians every month. Ask a question, respond to a question and better understand the law today!
FREE - Join Now
19 July 2018
1
0
1
Hi,
Hoping for some advise on where we stand. Rented a property for 2 years, were perfect tenants, always paid our rent on time, Husband is handy and fixed multiple issues without ever asking for reimbursement from owner (broken oven, shed that blew over in storm, light fittings that never worked etc).
Ended our tenancy on 2nd July, property was left in better condition than when we moved in (garden beds that were never weeded when we moved in were perfect, cleaned areas that weren't cleaned when we moved in) only damage was one small stain on the black carpet from a wooden TV unit - about the size of a can of coke - that couldn't be removed by professional cleaning - we have the receipts.
After final inspection (which we requested and we're denied attendance) the property manager came back with a list of 46(!) items for actioning, extremely petty things like the bins weren't left in the exact same spot as when we moved in. We obtained the keys to "rectify" these issues. Only attended to about 3 of them that we had genuinely forgotten, and just took photos of the rest as proof they were left in good condition. Funnily enough when they did a second inspection there were only 2 issues, the other 44 were suddenly fine despite us not doing anything.
Two days ago they sent us the bond disposal form, requesting $140 to repair the two issues they claimed were left. After almost 2 weeks of arguing with them my husband and I were sick of it and decided to just sign the forms and send them back. A few hours later the property manager emails back that they'd changed their mind and wanted to add more charges and would send us a new form.
We offered to pay the original request to avoid the hassle of dealing with them any longer, if they're going to add more charges we are happy to go to court and fight all the charges but just want to know what our odds are. The two damages they're claiming are the stain on the carpet and some oil stains on the driveway.
1. Would we have any luck arguing them replacing the entire room of carpet for one small stain? It doesn't affect the use of the carpet, we paid to have it professionally cleaned and the carpet is already 4 years old. The stain was also caused because they installed an air conditioning unit directly above the wooden item that left the stain, using the heater caused the laquer on the item to melt into the carpet. We literally didn't even know about the stain until we moved house.
2. When we came to look at the house before we moved in, the agent told us we could park 2 cars 1 behind the other onto the back patio (single garage) therefore when we moved in we listed that area as "carport" on the property condition report and listed that there were oil stains on the ground. Their evidence that we caused the damage is photos of my husband's car that he was working on for a year or so parked int he same spot over 3 different rent inspections. In each and every photo there is clearly a tarp under the vehicle.
Would really appreciate anyone's advice regarding these two issues and our chances of fighting them.